Good morning,
Arwana Citra Mulia:
Improvements Internally But Market Demand Still Weak
Arwana indicated
that there are significant developments in 4Q16, on:
1. Improved operational efficiency;
2. Higher sales volume;
3. Better sales mix.
Its market
penetration in the medium-end segment was the main driver of stronger 4Q16
sales, despite weak ceramic demand nationally. Nevertheless, with still-soft
national ceramic demand, we trim our forecasts on lower sales volumes. Our
lowered TP of IDR550 (from IDR635, 22% upside), implies FY17F P/E of 25x. Key
downside risk is cancellation of gas tariff cut as we have factored in lower
gas tariffs. BUY.
¨ Better
sales volume despite soft national ceramic demand. Arwana Citra Mulia
(Arwana) indicated that 4Q16 sales are likely to reach 12.7m sqm (+16% QoQ,
+11% YoY). Hence, FY16F sales volume may reach 47m sqm (+19% YoY), in line
with our expectations. In addition, finished goods’ inventory days declined
to 22-23 days in November (from 31 days in 3Q16).
¨ Higher
UNO sales. By
increasing its presence in the middle-end ceramic tiles segment via its UNO
products, Arwana is likely to register better sales mix in 4Q16. UNO
sales contribution increased to 38% in November (3Q16: 31%), while its
lowest-end product, Best Buy’s sales contribution – which provides the
lowest GPM – declined to 26% in November (3Q16: 51%).
¨ Lower
cost per unit.
Underpinned by higher capacity utilisation, Arwana can achieve better
economies of scale through higher efficiency in gas usage, and has managed to
reduce production costs per unit. Arwana said that its new plant-5 located in
Mojokerto, East Java, is running at maximum capacity. In addition, the
company has been able to reduce its product defect rate significantly. As a
result, gross profit margin (GPM) is expected to improve.
¨ Promising
2017. Arwana’s
management believes that 4Q16’s expected good performance is likely to
continue in 2017, driven by:
i. Higher sales
volumes – estimated to reach 52-55m sqm (11-17% YoY growth);
ii. Better sales mix –UNO
and regular ceramic sales’ contributions to increase to 40% each, while Best
Buy’sDony>Doncontribution to decline to 20%.
¨ Reduced
earnings estimates and TP. On the back of still-soft national ceramic
demand, we trim our earnings forecasts, driven by lower sales volumes–
FY17F-18F sales estimates lowered to 53m sqm (from 55m sqm) and 58m sqm (from
63m sqm). Consequently, our FY17F/18F earnings estimates have been cut to
IDR159bn and IDR240bn (-14.8% and -14.1%) respectively.
¨ We
cut our TP to IDR550. At our revised TP, the implied FY17F P/E is 25x. Key
downside risk to our call is the cancellation of gas tariff cut, which has
been regulated in Presidential Decree No. 40/2016. Based on our channel
checks at the Industrial Ministry, lower gas tariffs for the ceramic industry
is still being discussed. We have factored in a USD1/mmbtu gas tariff cut in
our forecasts. (Andrey Wijaya)
Link
to Daily report: Indonesia Morning Cuppa - 281216
|
|
Company
Update:
|
Malindo Feedmill
(MAIN IJ, Trading Buy, TP: IDR1,500), Banking On Lebaran
Despite a weakened IDR and DOC price
capping headwinds, Malindo deserves attention at this juncture. This is due
to:
1. Its attractive valuation – it is currently
trading at 10-9x FY16F-17F P/E, close to -2SD from its 5 years mean of 15x;
2. 4Q16 to be another strong quarter – average
broiler and DOC prices at ~15% higher than FY15’s numbers;
3. Its share price should perform next quarter
due to expectations of better sales volume prior to the Lebaran
season.
We
lower our FY17F-18F earnings by 6% and change our call to TRADING BUY (from
Buy) with a lower DCF-based IDR1,500 TP (from IDR2,100, 26% upside). This
implies 11x FY17F P/E, ie -1 SD from its 5-year historical trading band.
¨ Implications of the IDR’s
depreciation and day-old chicks (DOC) price capping. Assuming FY17 DOC
ASP of IDR4,800/bird, this segment’s margins should be similar to FY16’s
estimates (9M16: 5.3%). In addition, we assume a USD/IDR exchange rate of
13,700 for FY17. This means every 1% depreciation in the IDR against the USD
from our base case results in a 1% EPS reduction only. Note that Malindo’s
latest USD/IDR
debt composition stands at 10:90 vs the industry norm of 50:50.
¨ DOC margins expansion capped. Assuming mild
growth volumes (+5%) for its feed and DOC segments – as well as the
aforementioned assumptions above – Malindo ought to deliver +10% EPS growth
in FY17 vs our prior expectation of +20%. Our prior forecast expected the DOC
segment’s margins to improve further from FY16’s numbers – driven by improved
supply/demand dynamics, notably the DOC price hovering at IDR5,700-6,000/bird
prior to the price cap announcement.
¨ The key lies in the magnitude of the
feed price adjustments. Locally-produced corn, which makes up ~20%
of feed’s raw materials, has seen a price increase of 20% YoY. The poultry
companies, Malindo too, are managing to maintain feed segment margins by
replacing corn with wheat and increasing feed prices. Going forward, the firm
is looking to increase feed prices again. With relatively stable and
supportive broiler prices, Malindo might be able to pass on the additional
costs and recoup the DOC segment’s lower margins.
¨ Banking on good 4Q16 results and
Lebaran. With
DOC prices averaging at >IDR5,500 in 4Q16, Malindo is set to deliver
another quarter of strong results. These are scheduled to be announced by
end-Mar 2017. Furthermore, the share prices of poultry firms tend to perform
during the end 1Q until 2Q historically. This is due to strong demand for
chickens prior to Lebaran. This might lift Malindo’s valuations from
their current, depressed levels.
¨ Key risks to our call are
weakness in the IDR and margins compression if the Agriculture Ministry
disagrees with the feed price adjustments. (Norman Choong, CFA)
Link
to report: Banking On Lebaran
|
Sector
Outlook:
|
Cement (Neutral), Competition
Likely To Remain Intense……despite higher sales
We expect domestic
cement sales to pick up, driven by:
i. Accelerated
government infrastructure projects;
ii. Higher property
sales, supported by lower mortgage rates.
Still,
competition is likely to remain intense, triggered by the overcapacity
situation. EBIT margins are likely to narrow, driven by higher costs
following coal price increase. Hence, although valuations are attractive, we
remain NEUTRAL on the sector, with Semen Indonesia (SMGR IJ, NEUTRAL,TP:
IDR9,800) as our Top Pick.
¨ Better
sales ahead... Cement
sales are expected to rise on:
i. Ramping up of government infrastructure projects,
thanks to abundant revenue from the tax amnesty programme which is likely to
provide more funds for government spending;
ii. Increase in property sales on the back of lower
mortgage rates and the relaxation of the loan-to-value (LTV) threshold;
iii. Rising prices of commodities such as coal and CPO – the
main sources of income for people residing outside of Java – should boost
consumer spending.
These
factors should lead to higher cement sales in our view. We expect the
sector’s cement sales volume to grow by 7% YoY in FY17F.
¨ …but
competition likely to remain intense on overcapacity. Despite better
sales ahead, we expect the increase in supply to be faster than the growth in
demand. National production capacity was 83m tonnes pa as at end 2015. As at
end 2016, there was 6.4m tonnes pa of new capacity, and we expect an
additional 5m tonnes pa of new capacity in early 2017. Hence, we anticipate
further declines in production utilisation rates to 70% and 69% in FY16 and
FY17 respectively (from 75% in FY15).
Given the overcapacity in production, we
note that Indonesia’s cement producers have continued to reduce selling
prices to boost sales volumes and maintain market share. We estimate that the
combined new cement players’ market share increased to 9.8% in 3Q16 (2Q16: 9.5%,
1Q16: 8.3%).
We believe new cement companies are likely
to continue selling cement at huge discounts. Indocement (INTP IJ, NEUTRAL,
TP: IDR15,700), the second largest Indonesian cement maker, recently launched
its second-tiered brand, Rajawali, priced much lower than Tiga Roda,
its first-tiered brand, in order to compete with new players. This indicates
rising price competition in the industry, which would spill over to next
year.
¨ Higher
production costs. Indonesian
cement makers are likely to face new challenges stemming from higher fuel
costs starting 1Q17. In our sensitivity analysis, cement companies’ earnings
are likely to decline by 6-7% for every 10% increase in coal prices. This
year, cement producers are still benefitting from relatively low fuel costs,
as the bulk of coal purchases – which accounted for 25-30% of 9M16 COGS –
were made with 1-to 6-month contracts where prices were fixed.
¨ Neutral
sector stance.
Although Indonesian cement companies are trading at attractive valuations,
near to -2SD of 5-year average rolling forward P/E, we expect competition in
the domestic cement industry to intensify. Hence, we maintain our Neutral
stance on the sector.
¨ Our
Top Pick is Semen Indonesia since the company is the biggest beneficiary of
the recovery in cement sales growth across the country. It has a dominant
market share both within and outside Java. (Andrey
Wijaya)
|
Media
Highlights:
|
Corporates
Ciputra prepares capex amounted to IDR4trn
Nippon Indosari officially acquired a local
bread company in Philippines
Delta Dunia Makmur obtained contracts worth
IDR6.5trn
Garuda Indonesia eyes USD10bn annual
turnover by 2020 with its 'Sky Beyond' strategy
Pelayaran Tempuran Emas purchased a land in
Surabaya worth IDR174bn
Sampoerna Agro allocates IDR600bn-1trn for
capex
|
Our
Recent Publication:
|
Company update: Eagle High Plantations -
Flying High Like An Eagle
Link to report: Eagle High Plantations : Flying High Like An Eagle
|
Company update: Astra Agro Lestari -
Sizable Earnings Recovery Ahead
Link to report: Astra Agro Lestari:
Sizable Earnings Recovery Ahead
|
Company update: Astra International - LTV
Policy Relaxation To Rev Up Sales Even More
|
Company update: Waskita Karya – Key
Takeaways From Solo-Ngawi Toll Road Site Visit
|
Economic Update: Exports and Imports
Accelerate in November
Link to report: Exports and Imports
Accelerate in November
|
Economic Update: Bank Indonesia Maintains
The Key Rate At 4.75%
Link to report: Bank Indonesia Maintains
The Key Rate At 4.75%
|
Sector Update: Regional Plantation - 2017 –
a Bumper Crop Year?
Link to report: 2017 – a Bumper Crop
Year?
|
Company update: Perusahaan Gas Negara - Set
For a Reversal Of Fortune
Link to report: Perusahaan Gas Negara :
Set For a Reversal Of Fortune
|
Company Update: PP London Sumatra Indonesia
- Monetising The CPO Price Upcycle And Weakening IDR
Link to report: Monetising The CPO Price
Upcycle And Weakening IDR
|
Sector News Flash: Regional Oil & Gas -
Quite a historic deal, but.....
Link to report: Quite a historic deal,
but…..
|
Best regards,
Helmy Kristanto
Director
Head of Indonesia
Research
PT. RHB Securities
Indonesia